Top 8+ C++ Compiler for Android: IDEs & Apps


Top 8+ C++ Compiler for Android: IDEs & Apps

A toolchain enabling the interpretation of C++ supply code into executable applications on gadgets operating the Android working system. It bridges the hole between a general-purpose programming language and the particular structure and system calls of a cell platform. As an example, builders can leverage this performance to create high-performance purposes, video games, or libraries that instantly make the most of native {hardware} capabilities on Android gadgets.

Its significance lies in permitting builders to harness the facility and effectivity of C++ for Android improvement, bypassing the constraints of managed languages in performance-critical eventualities. Traditionally, this functionality empowered builders to port present C++ codebases to Android and craft subtle purposes demanding optimized useful resource utilization. The result’s usually quicker execution speeds, decrease reminiscence footprint, and direct entry to {hardware} options in comparison with purposes constructed solely with higher-level languages.

The following sections will delve into particular implementations, methodologies for cross-compilation, widespread improvement environments and challenges confronted throughout the creation of native C++ purposes for the cell ecosystem, providing a sensible information to successfully using this expertise.

1. Cross-compilation Toolchains

Cross-compilation toolchains are elementary to growing C++ purposes for Android, as they permit the creation of executable code for a goal platform (Android gadgets) from a improvement setting operating on a unique platform (e.g., Home windows, macOS, Linux). The discrepancy in architectures and working techniques necessitates using instruments able to producing platform-specific binaries.

  • Goal Structure Specification

    The toolchain permits builders to specify the goal structure for the generated code, akin to ARMv7, ARM64, or x86. This ensures that the ensuing binary is suitable with the particular Android system’s processor. With out specifying the proper structure, the appliance will both fail to run or carry out suboptimally. An instance is compiling an utility utilizing ARMv7 directions for a tool with an ARM64 processor. Whereas the system may run the ARMv7 code, it will not make the most of the total capabilities of the 64-bit processor.

  • System Libraries and Headers

    The toolchain contains important system libraries and header information tailor-made to the Android working system. These sources present the mandatory interfaces for interacting with the Android platform’s functionalities, akin to accessing {hardware} parts, managing system sources, or using Android-specific APIs. The NDK (Native Growth Equipment) is the core part right here, offering the API degree particular libraries. With out these headers and libraries, builders can be unable to entry Android particular performance from their C++ code.

  • Code Technology and Optimization

    The cross-compiler interprets C++ supply code into machine code optimized for the goal Android structure. This includes deciding on applicable instruction units, making use of optimization strategies, and producing environment friendly code sequences that leverage the system’s {hardware} capabilities. As an example, using NEON intrinsics for vectorized operations on ARM architectures, considerably boosting efficiency for duties like picture processing or audio encoding. Inefficient compilation can result in slower purposes and elevated battery consumption.

  • Linker and Packaging

    The toolchain’s linker combines compiled object information, libraries, and different sources right into a ultimate executable file or shared library appropriate for deployment on Android. This course of additionally includes resolving dependencies, adjusting reminiscence addresses, and packaging the appliance parts into the suitable format (e.g., APK or shared library). Right linking is important to make sure all parts of the appliance are bundled collectively and the appliance can begin efficiently. Incorrect dependency decision results in runtime errors.

In abstract, the choice and correct configuration of a cross-compilation toolchain is a necessary early step within the improvement of C++ based mostly Android purposes. With out a suitable toolchain, creating native Android purposes utilizing C++ turns into impractical as a result of elementary variations in processor structure and the working system setting.

2. Native Growth Equipment (NDK)

The Native Growth Equipment (NDK) is integral to leveraging C++ compilers for Android utility improvement. It gives the mandatory instruments and APIs for embedding native code instantly into Android purposes, facilitating performance-critical duties and code reuse.

  • Important Toolchain Part

    The NDK furnishes a cross-compilation toolchain, based mostly usually on Clang/LLVM, optimized for Android’s varied processor architectures (ARM, x86). This toolchain is the C++ compiler that interprets supply code into machine code executable on Android gadgets. With out the NDK, builders would lack the instruments required to generate suitable native code. For instance, compiling a posh physics engine in C++ to be used in a recreation would necessitate the NDK’s toolchain to make sure the code runs effectively on Android gadgets.

  • Android-Particular Headers and Libraries

    The NDK contains header information and libraries exposing Android’s native APIs. These allow C++ code to work together instantly with the Android working system, accessing options akin to {hardware} sensors, graphics rendering, and audio processing. This interplay is crucial for constructing purposes that require low-level management or entry to {hardware} capabilities. An actual-world instance contains accessing the digital camera feed for real-time picture processing inside a C++-based utility, reliant on the NDK-provided digital camera API headers and libraries.

  • Construct System Integration

    The NDK is designed to combine seamlessly with construct techniques akin to CMake and Gradle. This simplifies the method of compiling native code alongside Java/Kotlin code, streamlining the general utility construct course of. Construct system integration permits for automated compilation and linking of C++ code, lowering guide configuration and construct errors. As an example, a developer can configure Gradle to mechanically invoke the NDK’s construct instruments throughout the Android utility construct course of, guaranteeing that the native libraries are compiled and packaged accurately.

  • Debugging Help

    The NDK gives debugging capabilities, permitting builders to debug C++ code operating on Android gadgets. This contains options akin to setting breakpoints, stepping by means of code, and inspecting variables. Debugging is important for figuring out and resolving points in native code, which may be tougher than debugging managed code. For instance, utilizing Android Studio’s debugging instruments to step by means of C++ code that’s inflicting a crash or sudden conduct permits builders to pinpoint the supply of the issue and implement a repair.

In abstract, the NDK gives the whole setting to compile, hyperlink, combine, and debug native C++ code inside Android purposes. Its function extends past merely offering a compiler; it gives the important hyperlink between common goal C++ and the Android working system, empowering builders to create high-performance, feature-rich purposes.

3. ABI Compatibility

ABI (Utility Binary Interface) compatibility is a important concern when using a C++ compiler for Android improvement. It defines how compiled C++ code interacts at a binary degree with the Android working system and different native libraries. A change within the ABI can render beforehand compiled code incompatible with the up to date system, inflicting purposes to crash or malfunction. Due to this fact, the C++ compiler should adhere to the ABI specification mandated by Android to make sure right execution throughout completely different system architectures and OS variations. As an example, if a shared library compiled towards a earlier Android ABI is loaded into an utility constructed towards a more recent ABI, undefined conduct or crashes will doubtless happen as a consequence of variations in information buildings, operate calling conventions, or different low-level particulars. This necessitates cautious administration of compiler flags and NDK variations to take care of ABI compliance.

See also  6+ Tips: Living with a Tsunade Android (Ultimate Guide)

Failure to take care of ABI compatibility can have far-reaching penalties. It could require builders to recompile and redistribute purposes to help newer Android variations, impacting each improvement prices and consumer expertise. Furthermore, inconsistencies in ABI can introduce safety vulnerabilities. An instance of the significance of ABI compatibility is seen within the transition from 32-bit to 64-bit architectures in Android. Builders had to supply separate builds or make the most of fats binaries to help each architectures whereas sustaining ABI compatibility inside every structure. This ensures that purposes operate accurately on each older and newer gadgets with out requiring the consumer to manually replace or set up completely different variations.

In conclusion, ABI compatibility isn’t merely a technical element however a elementary requirement for profitable C++ improvement on Android. Understanding and adhering to the ABI requirements enforced by the Android NDK ensures utility stability, reduces upkeep overhead, and mitigates potential safety dangers. Cautious number of the compiler, related toolchain, and focused Android API degree is paramount for attaining and sustaining ABI compatibility throughout the Android ecosystem.

4. Efficiency Optimization

Efficiency optimization is inextricably linked to the utility of a C++ compiler for Android. The flexibility to leverage the facility and management provided by C++ is usually motivated by the necessity for execution speeds and useful resource administration superior to these achievable with higher-level languages. A C++ compiler for Android, subsequently, should supply options and capabilities designed to facilitate environment friendly code technology and runtime conduct. With out such optimization, the benefit of utilizing C++ is diminished, probably negating its profit in resource-constrained cell environments. For instance, recreation improvement usually depends on C++ for computationally intensive duties akin to physics simulations and rendering. An unoptimized C++ compiler may result in body fee drops and a degraded consumer expertise, undermining the selection of C++ as the event language.

The optimization course of can manifest at varied ranges. On the supply code degree, the compiler ought to help fashionable C++ options that promote environment friendly programming practices. These embody transfer semantics, compile-time analysis (constexpr), and environment friendly information buildings from the Commonplace Template Library (STL). On the intermediate illustration degree, the compiler ought to carry out aggressive analyses and transformations, akin to loop unrolling, operate inlining, and vectorization, to reinforce instruction-level parallelism. On the machine code degree, the compiler should generate optimized code sequences particular to the goal Android system’s structure, together with using SIMD directions (e.g., NEON on ARM) the place relevant. Contemplate picture processing purposes: an optimized compiler would mechanically vectorize pixel-by-pixel operations, drastically lowering processing time.

In conclusion, efficiency optimization isn’t merely an non-obligatory part however an integral side of any viable C++ compiler for Android. It’s the main purpose many builders select C++ within the first place. Compiler capabilities instantly affect utility pace, power consumption, and general consumer expertise. Steady developments in compiler expertise and optimization strategies are essential for sustaining the relevance and competitiveness of C++ within the evolving panorama of Android utility improvement. The problem stays in balancing aggressive optimization with compilation time and debugging ease, guaranteeing that builders can successfully leverage C++ with out sacrificing productiveness.

5. Debugging Capabilities

Debugging capabilities are a elementary part of any purposeful C++ compiler for Android improvement. The complexity inherent in native code, coupled with the nuances of the Android working system, necessitates strong debugging instruments. With out efficient debugging mechanisms, figuring out and resolving errors in C++ code turns into a major impediment, impeding improvement progress and probably resulting in unstable or malfunctioning purposes. For instance, reminiscence leaks, segmentation faults, and race situations are frequent points in C++ purposes, and with out debugging instruments, tracing the origin of those points is exceptionally troublesome. The C++ compiler acts as the muse upon which debugging instruments are constructed, producing debugging info that facilitates error detection and determination.

These capabilities usually manifest as help for normal debugging protocols like GDB (GNU Debugger), integration with IDEs (Built-in Growth Environments) akin to Android Studio, and the technology of debug symbols. Debug symbols comprise details about variable names, operate places, and supply code line numbers, enabling builders to correlate machine code execution with the unique C++ supply code. IDE integration streamlines the debugging course of by offering a user-friendly interface for setting breakpoints, inspecting variables, stepping by means of code, and analyzing reminiscence utilization. In eventualities involving multithreaded purposes, debugging instruments enable builders to look at the state of a number of threads concurrently, figuring out synchronization points or deadlocks. Moreover, superior debugging options akin to reminiscence leak detection and profiling instruments present insights into utility efficiency and useful resource consumption, enabling builders to optimize code for higher effectivity.

In conclusion, debugging capabilities aren’t an non-obligatory add-on however an integral and important a part of a C++ compiler for Android. They permit builders to successfully establish and resolve errors in native code, guaranteeing utility stability and efficiency. The mixing of debugging instruments with the compiler and improvement setting streamlines the debugging course of, permitting builders to effectively create strong and dependable C++ purposes for the Android platform. The absence of competent debugging options severely limits the usability of a C++ compiler for Android improvement in real-world eventualities.

6. Integration with IDEs

The mixing of a C++ compiler with Built-in Growth Environments (IDEs) is an important issue within the environment friendly improvement of Android purposes utilizing native code. The seamless interplay between the compiler and the IDE considerably impacts developer productiveness, debugging capabilities, and the general utility improvement workflow.

  • Code Completion and Syntax Highlighting

    An IDE, when correctly built-in with a C++ compiler for Android, presents clever code completion and correct syntax highlighting for C++ code. This performance reduces coding errors and hurries up the event course of by offering real-time ideas and visible cues. As an example, as a developer sorts a category title, the IDE can mechanically recommend obtainable strategies, based mostly on the headers and libraries offered by the NDK (Native Growth Equipment) and the underlying C++ compiler toolchain. Incorrect syntax highlighting, or lack thereof, can result in refined errors which might be troublesome to detect throughout compilation, making this characteristic important for developer productiveness.

  • Automated Construct System Integration

    An IDE can automate the construct course of by seamlessly integrating with construct techniques akin to CMake or Gradle, that are generally utilized in Android C++ improvement. This permits builders to compile and hyperlink native code instantly from throughout the IDE, with out having to manually invoke compiler instructions. For instance, a developer can configure the IDE to mechanically compile C++ code each time the mission is constructed, guaranteeing that the native libraries are at all times up-to-date. Handbook compilation, with out IDE integration, is time-consuming and susceptible to errors, particularly in advanced tasks with quite a few dependencies.

  • Debugging Help throughout the IDE

    The IDE gives a graphical interface for debugging C++ code operating on Android gadgets or emulators. This contains options akin to setting breakpoints, stepping by means of code, inspecting variables, and analyzing reminiscence utilization. The IDE leverages the debugging info generated by the C++ compiler to supply an in depth view of this system’s execution state. A developer may use the IDE’s debugger to step by means of a C++ operate that’s inflicting a crash, inspecting the values of variables to establish the supply of the error. With out IDE integration, debugging C++ code on Android requires utilizing command-line debuggers, that are harder to make use of and fewer environment friendly.

  • Venture Administration and Code Navigation

    The IDE facilitates mission administration by organizing supply code information, libraries, and different sources right into a structured mission hierarchy. It additionally gives code navigation options, akin to “go to definition” and “discover all references,” which permit builders to shortly navigate by means of massive codebases. For instance, a developer can use the IDE to shortly discover all situations of a selected operate name all through the mission. Disorganized tasks and problem in code navigation result in elevated improvement time and upkeep challenges, emphasizing the significance of IDE-facilitated mission administration.

See also  7+ Best Cricket Wireless Android Phones of [Year]

The tight integration of a C++ compiler with an IDE isn’t merely a comfort; it’s a necessity for productive and environment friendly Android C++ improvement. Options like code completion, automated builds, debugging help, and mission administration streamline the event course of, lowering errors and bettering general code high quality. Builders who select to work with out IDE integration usually face elevated complexity and decreased effectivity of their workflows.

7. Construct System Configuration

Construct system configuration is a elementary side of using a C++ compiler for Android improvement. The construct system orchestrates the compilation, linking, and packaging of native C++ code into shared libraries (.so information) appropriate for deployment on Android gadgets. A correctly configured construct system ensures that the C++ compiler is invoked with the proper flags, contains the mandatory header information and libraries from the Android NDK, and generates code suitable with the goal structure and Android API degree. With out right configuration, the C++ code could not compile, hyperlink, or run accurately on the goal Android system. For instance, if the construct system fails to incorporate the proper header information for the Android NDK, the C++ code will be unable to entry Android-specific APIs, resulting in compilation errors. Incorrect linking can result in runtime exceptions as a consequence of lacking dependencies. Due to this fact, efficient construct system configuration is paramount for profitable C++ improvement on the Android platform.

Frequent construct techniques utilized in Android C++ improvement embody CMake and ndk-build (a part of the NDK). CMake is a cross-platform construct system generator that simplifies the method of constructing native code for Android throughout completely different platforms (Home windows, macOS, Linux). It makes use of a CMakeLists.txt file to outline the construct course of, together with specifying the C++ compiler, supply information, embody directories, and goal libraries. Ndk-build, then again, is a construct system particular to the Android NDK. It makes use of Android.mk and Utility.mk information to outline the construct course of. An instance is utilizing CMake to generate a construct system that compiles a C++ physics engine right into a shared library to be used in an Android recreation. The CMakeLists.txt file would specify the C++ compiler to make use of, the supply information for the physics engine, the embody directories for the NDK, and the goal structure. This library would then be linked into the Android utility.

In conclusion, construct system configuration is an inextricable side of using a C++ compiler for Android. It gives the framework to orchestrate the compilation course of, handle dependencies, and configure the C++ compiler in response to the mission’s particular wants. Challenges in configuration can come up from the complexity of the Android construct course of, model mismatches between the NDK and the C++ compiler, and the necessity to help a number of architectures and API ranges. Nevertheless, mastering construct system configuration is crucial for creating environment friendly, secure, and high-performing C++ purposes for the Android ecosystem. These configurations present the pathway to dependable Android improvement for a C++ developer.

8. Library Administration

Efficient library administration is paramount when using a C++ compiler for Android utility improvement. The method encompasses the acquisition, integration, and upkeep of exterior code dependencies that complement the core utility logic. It instantly impacts construct occasions, utility dimension, runtime efficiency, and general maintainability.

  • Dependency Decision

    Dependency decision is the method of figuring out and retrieving the required libraries for a C++ mission. These libraries usually have their very own dependencies, creating a posh internet of necessities. Within the context of the Android platform, these libraries can vary from platform-specific APIs uncovered by the NDK (Native Growth Equipment) to third-party libraries offering specialised performance, akin to picture processing or networking. A failure to resolve dependencies accurately results in construct failures or runtime exceptions as a consequence of lacking symbols. As an example, an utility counting on a particular model of a cryptographic library could fail to load if the system lacks that model or gives an incompatible one.

  • Static vs. Dynamic Linking

    The choice to hyperlink libraries statically or dynamically has important implications for utility dimension and runtime conduct. Static linking incorporates the library code instantly into the executable, rising the appliance dimension however eliminating runtime dependencies. Dynamic linking, conversely, hyperlinks towards shared libraries at runtime, lowering utility dimension however introducing a dependency on the presence and compatibility of these shared libraries on the goal Android system. A recreation statically linking a big physics engine would end in a bigger APK, however it could remove the danger of the sport failing to run as a consequence of a lacking or incompatible system library. Selecting the suitable linking technique requires cautious consideration of the goal platform and utility necessities.

  • Model Management and Compatibility

    Sustaining model management over exterior libraries is crucial to make sure compatibility and forestall regressions. As libraries evolve, their APIs could change, probably breaking present code that depends on them. Using model management techniques and dependency administration instruments permits builders to trace library variations, revert to earlier variations if mandatory, and handle updates in a managed method. An Android utility utilizing a networking library that undergoes a significant API change could require code modifications to adapt to the brand new model, highlighting the significance of model management.

  • Licensing and Authorized Concerns

    Exterior libraries usually include particular licenses that govern their utilization and distribution. These licenses can vary from permissive licenses just like the MIT License, which permits at no cost use and modification, to extra restrictive licenses just like the GPL, which requires that spinoff works even be licensed underneath the GPL. Making certain compliance with the phrases of those licenses is essential to keep away from authorized points. Distributing an Android utility that features a GPL-licensed library with out adhering to the phrases of the GPL may result in copyright infringement claims. Due to this fact, cautious consideration of library licenses is an integral a part of library administration.

See also  8+ Top-Rated Best Android Car Radios for 2024

These sides of library administration are essential to harnessing the total potential of a C++ compiler for Android. A well-managed library ecosystem leads to purposes which might be extra strong, environment friendly, and maintainable. Conversely, neglecting library administration can result in construct failures, runtime errors, elevated utility dimension, and potential authorized problems, in the end undermining the advantages of utilizing C++ for Android improvement.

Incessantly Requested Questions

The next addresses frequent queries relating to using C++ compilers for Android utility improvement, clarifying technical points and dispelling potential misconceptions.

Query 1: Why make the most of a C++ compiler for Android improvement when Java/Kotlin are the formally supported languages?

A C++ compiler facilitates the creation of native code, enabling performance-critical duties akin to recreation improvement, advanced calculations, and {hardware} interplay to be executed extra effectively than with managed languages. It additionally permits porting present C++ codebases to the Android platform.

Query 2: What’s the Android NDK, and the way does it relate to C++ compilers?

The Android Native Growth Equipment (NDK) gives the important instruments, libraries, and header information mandatory for compiling C++ code for Android. It features a cross-compilation toolchain, usually based mostly on Clang/LLVM, optimized for varied Android processor architectures.

Query 3: How does ABI (Utility Binary Interface) compatibility have an effect on C++ improvement on Android?

ABI compatibility ensures that compiled C++ code can run accurately throughout completely different Android gadgets and OS variations. Modifications within the ABI can break compatibility, requiring recompilation and redistribution of purposes. The NDK enforces particular ABI requirements to take care of stability.

Query 4: What construct techniques are generally used with C++ compilers for Android?

CMake and ndk-build are ceaselessly employed construct techniques. CMake is a cross-platform construct system generator, whereas ndk-build is restricted to the Android NDK. These techniques handle the compilation, linking, and packaging of C++ code into shared libraries (.so information) for Android deployment.

Query 5: What are the first issues for efficiency optimization when utilizing C++ on Android?

Key issues embody leveraging fashionable C++ options, optimizing for the goal structure (e.g., ARM, x86), using SIMD directions (e.g., NEON), and punctiliously managing reminiscence utilization. Profiling instruments and efficiency analyzers are important for figuring out bottlenecks.

Query 6: What debugging instruments can be found for C++ code on Android?

Commonplace debugging protocols like GDB (GNU Debugger) are supported, usually built-in with IDEs akin to Android Studio. These instruments allow setting breakpoints, inspecting variables, stepping by means of code, and analyzing reminiscence utilization, facilitating the identification and determination of errors in native code.

In abstract, profitable C++ improvement for Android necessitates a radical understanding of the NDK, ABI compatibility, construct system configuration, efficiency optimization strategies, and debugging instruments.

The following part gives a sensible information to establishing a C++ improvement setting for Android.

Important Concerns for C++ Compiler Utilization on Android

Profitable integration of C++ into Android improvement calls for meticulous consideration to particular tips and finest practices, guaranteeing optimum efficiency and stability. Adherence to those suggestions mitigates frequent pitfalls and maximizes the advantages of native code execution.

Tip 1: Goal the Acceptable Android API Degree. Specification of the minimal supported Android API degree is important. Using newer APIs could preclude utility execution on older gadgets, limiting consumer accessibility. Conversely, focusing on an excessively low API degree could prohibit entry to performance-enhancing options and fashionable system functionalities.

Tip 2: Make use of Constant ABI Administration. The Utility Binary Interface (ABI) defines the low-level interface between compiled code and the working system. Guarantee constant ABI utilization throughout all native libraries and the appliance itself. Mismatched ABIs can result in runtime crashes and unpredictable conduct. Thorough testing on various Android system architectures is crucial.

Tip 3: Optimize for Goal Structure. Android gadgets embody a spread of processor architectures (ARMv7, ARM64, x86). Compiling code particularly for the goal structure maximizes efficiency. Make the most of compiler flags to allow architecture-specific optimizations, akin to NEON intrinsics for ARM gadgets, to leverage {hardware} acceleration capabilities successfully.

Tip 4: Prudently Handle Reminiscence Allocation. Handbook reminiscence administration inherent in C++ necessitates meticulous consideration to keep away from reminiscence leaks and fragmentation. Make use of sensible pointers (std::unique_ptr, std::shared_ptr) to automate reminiscence deallocation. Make the most of reminiscence profiling instruments to establish and deal with memory-related points proactively.

Tip 5: Prioritize Code Portability. Whereas native code presents efficiency benefits, portability throughout completely different Android variations and gadgets stays essential. Adhere to straightforward C++ practices and reduce reliance on platform-specific extensions. This strategy facilitates code reuse and reduces upkeep overhead.

Tip 6: Combine with the Android Construct System. Seamless integration with the Android construct system (Gradle, CMake) is paramount. Make use of these techniques to handle dependencies, compile native code, and bundle it into shared libraries (.so information) for inclusion within the Android utility. Right construct system configuration streamlines the event course of and minimizes integration errors.

Efficient utilization of a C++ compiler for Android depends on rigorous consideration to architectural specifics, reminiscence administration, and construct system integration. Diligent utility of the following pointers will result in extra strong and environment friendly native Android purposes.

The concluding part summarizes the important thing takeaways from this exploration of C++ compilers for Android improvement.

Conclusion

This discourse has totally examined the operate, implementation, and important issues surrounding a “cpp compiler for android.” The capability to translate C++ supply code into executable purposes throughout the Android ecosystem presents important benefits in efficiency and management. The cautious choice and configuration of cross-compilation toolchains, coupled with astute administration of the Android NDK and its related ABI necessities, type the muse for profitable native improvement. Moreover, efficient library administration and strong debugging capabilities are important parts for creating secure and maintainable purposes.

The strategic deployment of native code by way of a “cpp compiler for android” stays a robust instrument for growing performance-sensitive purposes. Builders are urged to rigorously weigh the complexities of native improvement towards the potential beneficial properties, prioritizing adherence to finest practices in reminiscence administration, architecture-specific optimization, and construct system integration. Continued developments in compiler expertise and the Android NDK promise to additional streamline the method, solidifying the function of C++ within the cell utility panorama. The diligent utility of the ideas outlined inside this text will foster the creation of strong and environment friendly Android purposes leveraging the capabilities of native code.

Leave a Comment